Family Dynamics – It is all Complicated

The time has come to write about this or I will not be able to move on.  So I will lay it all out here; all this baggage I’ve ruminating over the past few months.

It is a family thing, the past, the present, life and death… brought on by recent events involving my brothers.

I was the youngest of three, the only girl, with two full biological brothers. One brother 5 years older, William (who growing up was called Sonny) and the other Howard. 

Our mother left our father when I was just a baby and we grew up with our mother and step-father, Melvin. My oldest brother was 8 when Melvin came into our lives; I was only 3. 

Melvin was a good ol’ boy from east Texas. I wrote about him earlier and the other two step-fathers in my life. 

My life under Melvin was a little more sheltered as a girl but I did endure the pain of “whippings” as a child. Spanking is too kind of a word. These were harsh lashes with a leather belt that left strap marks and bruises across my legs and body. It was part of old southern child rearing method but it went beyond not sparing the rod.

My brothers on the other hand, encountered undue abuse from Melvin.  Under the rule of an authoritarian dominant man they suffered emotional and physical punishment well into their teens. One small step out of line was met with disproportionate severe corporal punishment. 

Maybe some sort of male rivalry was involved as well. Melvin was only 10 years older than Sonny.  I remember once when he was a senior in high school, Melvin came after him with a whip and swung at him with a chain.

I addition, before Melvin, Sonny witnessed alcoholic rages against our mother by our biological father. 

As soon as he graduated he left home and never returned. 

Howard, was just 16 months older than me. He was very intelligent.  He used to read the encyclopedia and memorize pages in the dictionary. He also played the trumpet and was a big fan of Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass. 

He was still living home when Melvin left our mother for another woman. Howard and I both had to make our way through the step-father who came next. 

In addition to all this physical abuse, over the years I harbored another family secret. I had endured sexual abuse by my brothers from a young age.

The stepfather that came next was far more interested in me than was proper. I could see the signs of coming abuse. I wanted out any way I could.

Thankfully, I met the son of a local restaurant owner, four years my senior. You could say, we fell in “love” or we both were both looking to escape. Either way we did escape and never looked back. 

We married and I left home at 14.

The reality of childhood for all of us in our home, behind closed doors, was that it was fraught with abuse, insecurity and trauma. There were good times but they were overshadowed by the fear that at any moment things could flip.

Within 2 years, 1968-70, my brothers and I had all move out of the abusive world and went our separate ways. 

We had only casual contact over the next 20 years. All of us were part of military families and lived miles apart. 

As I grew older effects from childhood sexual abuse became a stumbling block for me.   I had trust issues. I also had faith issues. I was looking for love in all the wrong places, as the country song goes.

In the wake of the major child abuse stories of the late 80’s, I was forced to come to terms with it. Thirty years old and I had never told a soul about the abuse.

I confronted both of my brothers with unsatisfactory results. It was written off as child’s play or something “I wanted,” by Howard. Sonny did not want to acknowledge it or discuss it. No resolution was coming. 

After the response I received from Sonny (the worst offender) we literally had very little to no contact for years. I did not see either brother again until 1999 at my grandfather’s funeral.  I never saw Howard again after that.

Both of my brothers were alcoholics.  Sonny quit drinking some 20 years ago but Howard, whose drinking started in his teens, was a life long alcoholic. He also had mental issues. 

Although I never saw Howard again after 1999, he would call me drunk in the middle of the night. He would tell me that the Italian mafia was after him and he was in the CIA. He would call my office and speak to whoever answered the phone and tell them all these same crazy stories. The final straw was when he called my house and spoke to my youngest son. 

He told my 16 year old he had gun and was going harm himself. That time and once before, I called the local police to do a welfare check on him.  

After this, I blocked him from all my numbers… work, home, cell phones. My mother told me that Howard didn’t know why I wouldn’t speak to him anymore.  I told her, “Yes he does.”

I saw Sonny again in 2012. He was living in Las Vegas and I flew down to see my Auntie who was in a tournament there. She arranged to have dinner with him but didn’t tell him I was there. I was the surprise. It was a cordial meeting, nothing more.  

Over the past 15 years he had many health issues. As our mother aged and dealt with dementia, I became her financial and health decision-maker. He would call and discuss issues he was seeing in mother. He would extend some encouragement and offer to help in any way he could but I discovered he couldn’t do much. 

I blogged about what I was going through dealing with my mother’s dementia and lamented that my brothers were no help, but thankfully they were no hindrance either. 

When my mother died neither of them came to her funeral. Sonny sent flowers and had called to say goodbye before she passed. Over the years he had been very faithful and loving to Mother. Although he did not visit for many years, he called her several times a week. 

Howard and mother had a hard relationship. He could call sober and all was well but when he called drunk, he was abusive. The last few years of her life she stopped taking his calls.  

Just days before she passed, I asked the social worker at the nursing home if she would call and tell him she was dying. She did and he agreed to speak to mother. She was no longer conscious but for all the things Howard did that were horrible, that day he stepped up to the plate. He said what needed to be said so she could pass in peace.  

I did not speak to him that day or anytime since she passed. 

All of this background to get to what I came to say today so that I can close the door on the past. Close the door because:

Both my brothers died this year. Four months apart. 

Sonny died July 22. Complications from cancer surgery years ago and cirrhosis of the liver. Even though he quit drinking 20 years ago, the damage was done. 

Howard died on November 20 just before Thanksgiving. His neighbors had found him unconscious in his house.

I was contacted because I was thought to be the only surviving blood relative. I told the hospital he had a daughter but she did not know him growing up. I contacted my niece and told her I would act as decision maker if she wanted. She thought about it and called me back and said she felt it was her responsibility. 

He was in the hospital for a week and never regained consciousness. We found out that he also suffered from cirrhosis of the liver, as well as he had cancer in his lungs and brain. 

In the end I am thankful my niece made the decisions.   I would have found it difficult. 

They are all gone now. My father, mother, all the step-fathers and my brothers. 

It is all so complicated and confusing in my mind. I was sad, but never shed a tear for my brothers although it seemed I should have. 

Being the only one left from your childhood family is very sobering. I turned 70 just a few months ago.  I have struggled the past few weeks with the reality of my mortality.   I hope to live past the 71 and 74 years my brothers had. 

Mostly, I pray that I can move beyond all the memories of the past that have kept my mind captive for so long. They are all gone, and in many ways, I am free.  

Thanks for the Memories

Thankful today for my Grandfather’s home movies and the memories of happy days.

Just by chance yesterday, I ran across a one of those videos. Before my grandfather died in 1999, he had taken all the old silent 16mm home movies he had taken of all his grandchildren in the 50’s and 60’s and recorded them onto VHS. You can hear the click, click, click of his huge reel-to-reel projector. Although there was no sound to the original video itself, he narrated the scenes as he recorded.

It warms my heart to hear his voice. In one place he says… “Ain’t she a cute little girl? That’s a sweet little ol’ girl, Patty-Watty (his pet name for me). You ought to see Patty-Watty now”

This video was likely taken at my uncles house on Thanksgiving… Houston, Texas. A warm November day in the south. My brother Howard and I were “fishing” in Uncle William’s pond. The interaction between me and my brother made me smile.

Hidden behind this happy day there are some sad memories. Thankfully there are no recordings of those, only the ones I relive in my mind. Sadly, over the years due to past abuse, alcohol and mental decline, we had very little contact after we left home and virtually none the last 15+ years.

But really, I needed to find this video yesterday. It healed my heart a little. Watching it reminded me that our relationship didn’t start out like things are today.

I got a call last week and this brother is in his last days…this comes just months after my oldest brother left this world.

It’s complicated, but seeing this video and some others has helped me sort out some of my feelings. For that I am very grateful.

It’s Over Now

My oldest brother died last Tuesday, July 22. Since then I have been tossing thoughts around in my head. I knew I had to write something. I just didn’t know how or what I wanted to say. It is complicated.

As adults, we had very little to no relationship. I would say polite contact, the past few years it revolved around our aging mother. She passed away four years ago and since then pretty much nothing. I would send him a message on his birthday. Sometimes he would respond, but usually not.

I often questioned myself why I even attempted to stay in touch, because as a child I was abused by him and the other one too. I guess mostly I wanted some kind of resolution to the past, but I feel he wanted to forget it, sweep it under the rug, hide it in the closet. That’s where a lot of family secrets go.

There were a lot of family secrets and dead bones in our family. I’ve written about them before. This post – https://emyloomwordswovenwithinmyheart.com/2020/09/10/sexual-abuse-teen-moms-and-family-curses/ – questions whether these acts were a curse on our family line. If so why is the girls who suffer the lifelong side effects?

When I was little, I looked up to him. He was five years my senior, handsome and smart. The abuse started when I was maybe 10 years old. It continued until he left for the marines at age 18. He went on to “make” something of his life, I guess. He had a long career in the Marines; started as a private and moved up to warrant officer and then a commissioned officer. After the Marines he went back to school and got a teaching degree. He taught handicap children and from what I heard from my mother, he was highly loved and respected.

Good for him but he never wanted to put the past to rest. He never addressed what happened. I know he did not have an easy childhood. He was 5, 6 maybe even 7 when he witnessed verbal and extreme physical abuse by our alcoholic father on our mother. Were we all just damaged goods and we damaged each other?

The last time I was in the city where he lived I texted him to see if he wanted to meet. It was four years ago actually, just after our mother passed. He didn’t attend her funeral, but my mother had told me he was sick and she would understand. She had been telling me he was sick for years, and she understood why he never came to Texas to see her. Anyway, he didn’t want to see me then either, not even for coffee. He told me he wasn’t “public ready” and declined to meet.

So why did I make all these attempts? Maybe I wanted some closure, some explanation, some sign of remorse, hoping for some request for forgiveness? Anyway it is not coming now.

The Friday before he passed his wife called to tell me that his days were short. She said he requested very little but asked her to call and let me know. OK, she let me know. Was it an effort on his part to reach out before he died, to settle the past? Evidently not. I wrote back and asked if he wanted me to come see him, but recalled that he did not want to see me in 2021. I told her if she thought it was appropriate she could tell him that,

“I always loved him and I release him from any harm or hurt from he past. I only want this journey to be peaceful and full of joy on the other side when he is reunited with mother…”

Not forgiveness but letting go.

I did not hear back from her until Tuesday. She sent a text that said, “Andy passed away this morning.”

This all left me with so many mixed emotions. There is nothing left to resolve on this side. I want to move on. I am sad and angry at the same time. Tears may have welled up for a moment but I did not even cry. I wondered was his passing even worth my tears? It sounds harsh, mean and cold. However, he lived his life and I lived mine and his is over now.

One side note about my brother. He was born the same day as Princess Anne, Queen Elizabeth’s only daughter. He died the same morning as Ozzy Osbourne. What a contrast.

Summer 1968

Four Husbands No Fathers

I wrote a verse in 2014 on Father’s Day, called “Fatherless,” because my biological father was out of my life before I had any memories of him. My mother was married three more times each time bringing a new father figure. Last month I found out the last one had died and left me contemplating the roll of each.

My biological father was a tormented soul. He served in the Navy in WWII and I am told he was never the same when he returned. His torment drove him alcohol which became a demon to him. He would drink, become abusive, and then take his rage out on my mother. I heard once, overheard, that her final straw was when he held a gun to my head and dared her to scream. {{Deep breath}} yeah, that was hard to hear. Thankfully, she dug down deep, and even though she was a young 25 year old with small children she left him.

I have no memory before that and he never visited us but when I was 27, I went back to Virginia to visit my Auntie, his sister. He was in the VA hospital suffering ill health from years of alcohol abuse. With my Auntie by my side, I went to see him there. I have to say, I only went out of curiosity. He appeared to be an old man with many regrets. He told a couple of innocent stories about memories he had when I was young. That was it, maybe less than an hour. Strangely enough, I don’t remember how our visit ended. Did I extend an obligatory hug? I don’t know but I doubt it, I was very protective back then.

When my mother left my bio-father, we lived in Texas. She was supporting three small children on her own and working at the Walgreen’s lunch counter in downtown Houston. It was there she met a young East Texas bull rider six years her junior. He was tall and handsome with red hair. They married in 1959; I was three and half years old.

He was not an educated man, but a hard working good ol’ country boy. He did construction work, dug ditches and worked hard to support us. He became my daddy. He held me, brushed my hair and provided lots of love and affection which was tempered by the fact he was a old-school disciplinarian – spare the rod, spoil the child. Any act of disobedience was met with a “whipping” often with a belt. I went to school many times with welt marks across my legs. Today such actions would send child protective services to the home but back then that was the way it was.

When I was fourteen, he left my mother for another woman and just like that he was gone out of my life. I saw him a few times over the years. In the last twenty or so years he would call me on my birthday. I think he remember it because it was two days before his.

As quickly as the tall red-head left, on the rebound, my mother within six months jumped to another marriage. This man was eight years my mother’s senior. He was rough, from North Carolina and he had been in jail, supposedly for check fraud. I don’t know what his intentions were with my mother, but he was wholly inappropriate with me. He was not a father but an abuser. He moved my mother from Texas to Florida where his son lived. I married early and was removed from the situation. After only 3 years my mother left him and moved back to Texas.

Back in Texas, my mother connected with my father-in-law (correct, my husband’s father) and they married. I had always had a strained relationship with him. He was also southern Texas old-school with a bit of the alcohol demon mixed in as well. He could be sweet and caring, or sarcastic and abusive… the more alcohol the more abusive. My kids loved him and his grumpy, cantankerous ways. He was the kind of grumpy old grandpa that young boys find fascinating; they laughed and wondered over his antics.

However, I never understood why my mother tolerated this behavior, but I think she felt she could show him some sort of acceptance and love he lacked in his life. I don’t even want to get into how many run-ins I had with him. He could be inappropriate too, with other women including me. He never became physically abusive like the prior one, mostly inappropriate suggestive speech. Some of it was done in a joking good-old-boy way often in front of my mother.

To say our relationship was contentious was an understatement. I hated the way he treated my mother but my mother would defend him. Once at Father’s Day I made a comment to my mother that I didn’t have to worry about that holiday and she became upset and offended. I told her I did not consider him my father. She harshly reminded me of that statement for many years and would tell me that he really loved me… well, he had a strange way of showing it.

Now they are all gone.

A few years ago I found out that the abusive husband from North Carolina had died in 1980, just seven years after my mother left Florida. I feel nothing. He was dead to me the moment she left him. That marriage was a mistake in every way, and he was certainly not any sort of father figure.

My biological father died in 1986 just three days after his 60th birthday. He died of lung cancer in that same VA hospital I visited him in just a few years earlier. My mother called to tell me he had died. My reaction was unexpected. I cried and cried and I could not understand why. I had not known him at all except through hearing about him and I only had one memory of him. It was perplexing. After a while I became to understand that I was mourning the loss of what could have been, what might have been, but was never to be.

The last one, (my ex-father-in-law) stayed married to my mom for thirty-four years. He was stubborn, cantankerous and abusive until the end. I was there when he passed in 2009, as was my husband, my step sister, my ex-husband (now step-brother) and his wife. It was a hard watching my mom go through this loss. I did what I could to honor her wishes and help her through this period. I bought yellow roses for his casket but I did not shed a tear.

The most touching thing that stays with me about the day he died was that as one-by-one we slowly left the room, my ex-husband stayed behind with his father. As I looked down the hallway, I saw my current husband waiting as if standing guard outside the room while my ex said his goodbyes. When my ex left the room, my husband reached out and embraced him. It was surreal watching the two men in my life, one grieving a loss and the other comforting him.

Finally, I learned last month that the man who had been my father through my childhood years had died. I had heard from him like I said off and on through the years but much more in the last 3 or 4 years. Several times when I would go to Texas to see my mom, I would try to work in a visit. However, Texas is a big place and there was never enough time.

The past year after my mom passed away he began calling me more often. Even though he was a strict hard disciplinarian , I certainly had an affection for him. He filled a void in little girls life, but it was not going to take up where we left off fifty-three years ago. When he left my mother, he abandoned me. The last year he was in a nursing home and began calling me at work, and after the calls got more and more frequent I blocked his number from my work phone.

Early this year he called me one night at 11 pm, I was already asleep and did not answer. He left a very strange message that seemed like he was confused and thought he had called someone else. After a few days I tried to call him back and got no answer. When our birthdays rolled around in September, I called his cellphone, it was disconnected. I called the nursing home and they would not tell me anything. I looked for obituaries, nothing.

Finally, I found a phone number for his younger brother. I called and left a message within the hour he called me back. He told me his brother had passed away March 30 which was only few weeks after the strange late night call.

His brother didn’t really remember me; he was nineteen years younger than his brother and three years younger than me. I thanked him for calling me back and told him that I would be forever grateful to his brother for the role he played in my life. He was harsh at times. He was barely 19 when he married my mother. A woman 6 years older with 3 children. Grateful, but no tears, no grief. Strange really. It has been on my mind the past few weeks as I tried to sort out these feelings. Why did I not have any emotional reaction to his death?

Now they are all gone. Did they shape who I am? I think it comes back to my verse so many years ago, I was – Fatherless. That is truly how I see it.

Fatherless

Celebrate your Fathers today,
Know that you are blessed
To have had a loving guiding protector,
That allowed your soul to rest.

To a girl without a Father,
Life lessons were hard learned.
Looking to fill that empty space
In a heart that always yearned.

Substitutes stepped in at times
With promises to love and protect,
But they always went their own way
and left a heart with reject.

I envied and I longed
For a Father to hold in times of need,
Offering comfort With his strong arms ~
In every word and deed.

Now I know, I always had a Father dear.
Present at every trial and turn, sending down his love;
Each time life’s journey overwhelmed,
He was watching from above.

Father’s Day, yet I have none on earth to call my own,
But in heaven I have a wondrous One.
And I will see my Abba’s face,
When my days on earth are done.

© Trish B. 2014

Link to 2014: https://emyloomwordswovenwithinmyheart.com/2014/06/15/fatherless/

Sexual Abuse, Teen Moms and Family CuRseS

I am a child sexual abuse survivor. I was a teen mom. My mother was a teen mom and I found out later also sexually abused. Now my granddaughter is pregnant. She also abused by her mother’s boyfriend. Is this a pattern or a curse? Is there cause and effect in play?

My mom’s story goes a like this. She was raised in an upper middle class family in south Texas. She had a stern strong father figure who dominated the home and a subservient mother the traditional 1930’s and 40’s.

The family did many recreational things together. Her father owned a boat and they spent many weekends out on the coast of Galveston enjoying the sun and sea.

When my mother was 14 her life was uprooted and turned around. Her father met another woman and divorced her mother after 23 years of marriage. This sent her mother into a state of mental decline. She took my mother and went back to her family in Virginia but long before my mother left for VA there were family secrets. She had been sexually abused by her oldest brother.

In VA she was as lost as her mother, no friends, insecure, in a new place, no emotional support. It was then she met a handsome young man just out of the Navy, seven years her senior. She was looking to be loved, looking to belong, looking to escape. They eloped when she was only 16. She became a mother shortly after her 17th birthday.

Me: Raised in a poor southern home with no memory of that tall veteran my mother married. After years of battery and abuse she left him and returned to Texas. Her father, now wealthy, helped out meagerly by doling out dribs and drabs of support. There she met and married a “good old country boy. “

Raised in East Texas he had no education but left home and hit the road as a bull rider. He was a hard worker. He did odd jobs and dug ditches and gave all he earned in support to my mother and her 3 children. He also was a strict southern raised disciplinarian… spare the rod spoil the child. Do not answer back, do not speak up, do not question or you will be beat into submission. I was a shy compliant child that made straight A’s in school, even so, I was “whooped” regularly with a belt.

Just like my mother I had two older brothers. However, unfortunately, both mine sexually abused me along with other family “friends” starting when I was young, very young; it began long before I started school. I have always had an old soul and at the time, I felt a huge responsibility to keep this abuse to myself. Along with the fact I was told to keep silent. My mother was also emotionally fragile and I knew it would destroy her. After all, how could she know or imagine what was going on? Imagine my anger and disappointment at her failure to protect me when I found out, many years later, that she should have known.

At 14, the “good old country boy” left my mother for another woman. Really the only father I had known was now gone. My mother, like her own, went through an emotionally tail spin and remarried very quickly (6 months) to the first man that paid attention to her. Problem was he paid also paid attention to me. Grabbing, kissing, inappropriate speech and once again, I was silent and protecting my mother.

Around that time a tall young man, 18, appeared on the scene. The son of a local restaurant owner who was a friend of the grabber. He offered an escape, perhaps he was looking to escape too or in search of an unspoken need. Many of us had wounded souls. I don’t know for certain but at 14, I was pregnant; we quickly married and left Texas in the rear-view mirror.

When I look back the driving force behind my actions, I see I was just getting away. Getting away from the creeper and the emotional suffocation; longing to just be free, protected and to breathe.

I was a mother at 15.

As much as I longed for one, thankfully I never had a daughter, but three sons. Possible this curse of abuse, looking for love and escape was broken.

At 48, I became a grandmother to a beautiful blue-eyed blonde. Her parents unmarried, were raising her jointly. I prayed for her divine protection. Her mother emotionally unbalanced on bipolar medication did some very strange things. Her father, my son, a military veteran and police officer offered a strict but loving solid foundation. She was shifted uncontrollably through the whirlwind of these two very divergent worlds.

My heart was once again broken when I learned last year that my beautiful granddaughter had been abused by her mother’s boyfriend. This abuse going back several years was revealed when she was 16. When her mother was confronted with evil, she defended her lover. She called her daughter a liar and many other things as she denied this evil. Now because of legal issues there is no contact between them. My granddaughter mourns for her mother, she still loves her (hard for a child to forget the good memories) but she is heartbroken over the betrayal that her mother has chosen her abuser over her.

Abuse, pain and loss. It repeats, and now a one year later my 17-year-old granddaughter is pregnant.

Was she looking for love and acceptance? Was she looking to escape? My heart breaks for the difficulties and trials that lie ahead for her.

What is this? I often wonder is there a family or generational curse? Women abused, taken advantage of by men who walk away and leave their victims to pick up the pieces. Searching to fix our brokenness. As adults we try to put the pieces of what we lost, the innocence, our childhood, our sexuality back together into a life that can bring happiness and success. Some of us succeed better than others.

Look around, listen to the news it is prevalent. A shame and stain on society that many turn their back on and refuse to see. It is a societal curse rooted in the most vile evil. How can we break this cycle?

See us, save us.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2722133/